Press "Enter" to skip to content

Federal Lawsuit Challenges Pentagon’s Project Meridian Over Transparency and Conflicts of Interest

A Pentagon advisory panel tasked with shaping the future of American warfare is now at the center of a federal lawsuit — and the core question is whether the military’s highest-ranking leaders are getting advice they’re legally allowed to receive. Three government watchdog organizations are asking a court to intervene, arguing that the Defense Department broke federal law when it assembled the group.

The panel in question is called Project Meridian. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth announced it in September, appointing Elon Musk, Palmer Luckey, and former House Speaker Newt Gingrich as its directors. Its mission: map the trajectory of future warfare. Nineteen additional members were also appointed to participate, the majority of whom have documented financial ties to the defense industry or are political allies of the current administration.

What the Lawsuit Claims

The complaint was filed earlier this month by Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), Public Citizen, and the Project on Government Oversight (POGO). The groups argue that Project Meridian violates the Federal Advisory Committee Act, or FACA — a federal law designed to ensure that government advisory panels operate transparently, serve the public interest, and include balanced representation.

According to the plaintiffs, the Defense Department failed on several counts. It did not publish notice in the Federal Register, which would have given the public a chance to review materials and submit comments. It also did not consult the General Services Administration to determine whether the research serves the public interest — both steps required under FACA.

In a statement, CREW President Donald K. Sherman said FACA

“sets clear requirements about transparency and avoiding conflicts of interest.”

He argued the Defense Department must either comply with those requirements or shut the project down entirely.

Who’s on the Panel — and Why It Matters

The financial stakes tied to Project Meridian’s membership are significant. SpaceX, the company Elon Musk leads, holds approximately $8 billion in defense contracts. Anduril Industries, founded by Palmer Luckey, holds approximately $25 billion in defense contracts. Other participants include executives from Oracle, Saronic Technologies, Hadrian Automation, and Agility Robotics, along with investors in other defense-related companies.

The lawsuit challenges not just those with direct financial interests, but also participants without them. According to the complaint, those members

“do not provide fair balance”

either — their backgrounds are largely tied to companies already represented on the panel or to advancing the administration’s political agenda. The complaint notes that the panel

“has no meaningful representation from any person or entity with a record of advocating for restraint in the proliferation and use of military assets.”

Sherman put the concern more directly, arguing that federal law prohibits the Defense Department from

“getting advice in secret, by defense contractors with enormous potential conflicts of interest.”

He said the department is

“soliciting private counsel from contractors about military capacity, including the president’s largest political benefactor.”

What the Watchdog Groups Are Asking For

Before going to court, the three organizations say they offered to make their own subject-matter experts available to Project Meridian. They received no response. Leaders of Public Citizen and POGO warned that the panel would

“very predictably”

recommend increased government spending on

“AI-enabled weaponry”

and would

“further skew national security policy toward corporate priorities, and away from the public interest.”

The panel was given a deadline of January 28 to deliver a 30-page report of its findings to Hegseth. The Defense Department also commissioned the nonprofit Mitre Corporation to help coordinate the project’s work.