In a unique face-off for the leadership of the Maricopa County Superior Court’s clerk’s office, a 19-year-old student is challenging a seasoned former Republican state lawmaker. Both contenders are focused on ensuring the office functions efficiently.
The clerk’s responsibilities are extensive, encompassing management of court records, fee collection, evidence handling, and passport processing, all supported by a team of nearly 700 employees.
Distinct Visions for the Clerk’s Office
Democratic candidate Seb Matta acknowledges his youth but emphasizes his readiness to lead. “I’m very willing to learn from the staff, but I have good ideas. I know I have good ideas, and I know that I’m very capable of leading this office,” Matta stated.
His opponent, Republican Jeff Dial, suggests Matta is using the position as a political stepping stone, an accusation Matta refutes. Dial expressed concern about Matta’s readiness, noting, “I like to see young people get involved with politics. I think many times the best place for younger people to get involved with politics is not necessarily where they would be running a department of almost 700 people.”
Dial also criticized Matta for filing a late campaign finance report, questioning his ability to manage the clerk’s office’s significant financial responsibilities. Matta attributed the delay to an unresponsive accountant but assured that he would resolve the issue and pay any fines.
Backgrounds and Campaigns
Matta, a Phoenix native studying philosophy, is running his campaign solo and has raised over $20,000 from national donors. Meanwhile, Dial, a former Arizona state representative from 2011 to 2016, currently works as a realtor and serves on multiple boards. He plans to scale back his real estate work if elected.
Currently, the clerk’s office lacks a permanent head following the retirement of Jeff Fine and the brief tenure of Joseph Malka, who was appointed by Governor Katie Hobbs. The acting clerk is now Chief Deputy Nancy Rodriguez.
Debate Over Experience and Age
Former Clerk Chris DeRose, a Republican, argues that Matta’s age should not be a disqualifying factor, urging focus on the candidates’ platforms and experience. Matta has actively engaged with the community, attending numerous district meetings and receiving support from the Maricopa County Democratic Party.
Motivations Behind Candidacy
Matta’s interest in the clerk’s office began early, influenced by his father’s work as a car crash investigator. He insists his candidacy is motivated by a genuine interest in the role, not as a career stepping stone. Dial, encouraged by a former clerk, sees an opportunity to improve the office and has discussed his candidacy with family and connections.
Shared Goals and Diverging Accusations
Both candidates aim to enhance online filing and multilingual accessibility of court resources, though they accuse each other of inconsistency. Matta, who speaks multiple languages, has advocated for resource accessibility since February, while Dial highlights his campaign’s multilingual website.
Matta plans to facilitate e-filing for probate matters to reduce costs and streamline procedures. Dial agrees on the importance of e-filing and aims to improve the phone system for quicker, more efficient service.
Both candidates emphasize the importance of the existing staff, with Matta reassuring them about job security and gradual implementation of changes. Dial focuses on fostering a supportive work culture with strong customer service.
DeRose advises the incoming clerk to engage with the staff through a “listening tour” to leverage their expertise and dedication.
