
As artificial intelligence (AI) continues to weave itself into various sectors of society, its implications in education are raising significant concerns. Educators across the United States are increasingly worried about AI’s influence on students’ learning and critical thinking capabilities, as a new poll reveals.
An NPR/Ipsos poll indicates that over half of the teachers surveyed—54%—are apprehensive that AI could impede students’ ability to think independently. This sentiment is backed by studies suggesting that reliance on AI chatbots can diminish critical thinking, creativity, and attention spans.
Christa Corricelli, a special-education teacher at Saugus Middle/High School, expressed concerns that students who lack intrinsic motivation might experience a decline in critical thinking skills over time. “I think students who aren’t already intrinsically self-motivated to be critical thinkers, like that top 1% of the class … I think people who are not already that personality type, we’re going to see those critical thinking skills atrophy over time,” she told NPR.
Mallory Newall, a senior vice president at Ipsos, noted that teachers are apprehensive about AI fundamentally reshaping education. “They have serious concerns about AI’s impact on how they relate to their students and how students relate to each other,” Newall explained to NPR.
Despite these concerns, some educators like Michele Naber, a biology teacher at El Toro High School in California, are finding ways to integrate AI into the classroom. Naber uses AI to instruct students in evaluating the accuracy of AI-generated content. She encourages students to critically assess AI outputs, such as comparing ChatGPT descriptions of animals with their real-life characteristics. “That’s one of the things that has to be taught: You can’t take it literally,” Naber stated.
While skepticism about AI in education exists, 60% of surveyed teachers admitted using AI tools for administrative tasks. Naber shared with NPR that AI aids in generating answers for multiple-choice tests, reducing the time spent on such tasks from an hour to just five minutes. “That’s helpful,” she remarked.
Interestingly, it’s not just educators who are wary of AI’s expanding role. Recent college commencement ceremonies have seen graduates express disapproval towards AI, including incidents where commencement speakers promoting AI were met with boos. A malfunctioning AI reader even disrupted one Arizona community college’s graduation ceremony.
Filmmakers and artists also share mixed feelings regarding AI. While some like Darren Aronofsky and Martin Scorsese are embracing the technology, others, including 20-year-old Backrooms director Kane Parsons, are critical. In an interview, Parsons expressed his disapproval, saying, “I think I’m in the same boat as most well-adjusted people. If I could snap my fingers and make generative AI disappear forever, I probably would. Creatively, I get no enjoyment from using those tools. It defeats the purpose entirely for me.”
The backlash against AI extends to legal battles as well. A group of teenage girls has filed a lawsuit against Elon Musk’s xAI after its chatbot Grok was used to create explicit images without their consent. “xAI chose to profit off the sexual predation of real people, including children, despite knowing full well the consequences of creating such a dangerous product,” stated Vanessa Baehr-Jones, the plaintiffs’ lawyer.
SEE ALSO:
Alcorn State University 1st HBCU To Fully Integrate AI
Professors Fear AI Is Ruining Education. Students Say It Depends






