Picture yourself in the office, indulging in a box of budget-friendly Valentine’s chocolates during your lunch break. As you savor the treat, you catch someone watching, triggering a moment of self-consciousness. It’s not the taste that’s the issue, but the potential judgment from others for indulging in something considered inexpensive.
This scenario is a common experience for many. Whether it’s enjoying affordable chocolates or participating in programs like free school lunches or showcasing visible tattoos, people often feel a tinge of embarrassment about their consumption choices.
We are social marketing researchers who study stigma in marketing, and we use the term “consumption stigma” to describe the judgment people face over their use of certain products, despite there being no inherent issue with them.
The Weight of Consumption Stigma
Being judged for one’s consumption choices can be mentally taxing. The feeling of stigma can undermine self-esteem, increase anxiety, and alter behaviors in daily life. What begins as a slight embarrassment can escalate into a constant worry about societal perceptions.
Our review of 50 studies on marketing stigma reveals that responses to consumption stigma range widely. Some individuals choose to conceal their habits or steer clear of certain products to avoid judgment. Others modify their behaviors to minimize scrutiny. On the opposite end, some challenge the stigma, working to destigmatize these consumption choices for themselves and others.
Interestingly, to dodge stigma, individuals might opt for pricier or more socially acceptable alternatives, even if it strains their budget. Consider someone who switches to a high-end chocolate brand at work, not for the flavor, but to evade embarrassment.
This shift can lead to unsustainable spending patterns, driven more by societal pressure than genuine need. The effects can be severe, such as a child forgoing a free lunch to avoid ridicule or a veteran declining mental health services due to fear of judgment.
For businesses, consumer avoidance due to stigma can result in decreased demand, unrelated to product quality or value. If stigma becomes widespread, it could potentially lead to lost revenue and diminished brand reputation.
PixelsEffect/E+ via Getty Images
Reclaiming the Story
Stigma’s strength lies in its portrayal as reality, but it’s fundamentally a social judgment—a narrative about what certain choices imply about a person. When left unchallenged, stigma persists, but questioning it can start to diminish its impact.
One method to combat stigma is by reshaping the narrative around consumption. By openly embracing their choices instead of concealing or justifying them, individuals can weaken stigma’s hold.
For instance, a consumer who proudly opts for budget-friendly store brands at the supermarket, viewing it as smart shopping rather than a compromise, can change perceptions. When people wear their choices with pride—be it inexpensive chocolates or secondhand clothing—those choices lose their negative connotations. As behaviors become less taboo, they become harder for others to use as a basis for judgment.
While stigma doesn’t vanish instantly, research indicates that as more people stop hiding certain behaviors, societal perceptions begin to shift. What is embarrassing today could be standard tomorrow. For instance, fashion research has shown that wearing a veil, once stigmatized, became normalized and even fashionable as more women adopted it publicly.
Enjoying an affordable chocolate shouldn’t need defending. A plain travel mug holds water just as well as a branded one. A generic sweater provides the same warmth as a designer piece. Yet, many feel compelled to explain or upgrade their choices to avoid judgment. Recognizing consumption stigma clarifies these feelings as societal, not personal, constructs.
Ultimately, the key might not be consuming differently, but thinking differently. By ceasing to view everyday choices as moral indicators, a more honest and compassionate marketplace can emerge.
