Harvey Weinstein Retrial: Accuser Faces Rigorous Defense Examination
In a New York courtroom, Harvey Weinstein’s retrial unfolded as his defense team rigorously questioned accuser Jessica Mann. The lawyers aimed to dissect the complexities of Mann’s past interactions with the former Hollywood titan, already a central figure in the #MeToo movement.
This marks the third time Mann has undergone cross-examination concerning her allegations against Weinstein. However, new defense attorneys are now representing the embattled ex-studio head. While the proceedings were intense, they lacked the emotional intensity of Mann’s previous testimonies.
Weinstein’s lawyer, Teny Geragos, began her line of questioning by delving into Mann’s intricate feelings towards Weinstein, which included some consensual encounters amidst the alleged misconduct. During earlier questioning by prosecutors, Mann revealed that she felt a form of affection for Weinstein, attributing it to his kindness and support of her personal and professional aspirations. “It was the validation,” Mann explained when asked what drew her to him.
During the cross-examination, Geragos probed Mann’s description of “human moments” shared with Weinstein, referencing an incident where Mann slapped him, thinking it was part of a consensual act. Mann clarified that she was more moved by Weinstein’s response: “Jess, that’s not you.”
The retrial has Weinstein facing charges for an alleged assault on Mann in March 2013 at a New York hotel. Although previously convicted in 2020, that verdict was overturned on appeal. In a subsequent retrial, the jury was unable to reach a consensus on the rape charge.
Mann also claims Weinstein raped her again later in Beverly Hills, although there have been no charges filed for that incident. “He just treated me like he owned me,” Mann conveyed to the jurors.
While Mann acknowledged some consensual interactions, she asserted that the alleged rapes involved force and her vocal refusals. Conversely, Weinstein’s defense argues that the relationship was consensual, with Mann benefitting professionally from her association with Weinstein before later accusing him amidst the #MeToo revelations.
The pair first met in early 2013 at a Los Angeles-area party, with Mann describing herself as an aspiring hairstylist and actor at the time. Weinstein soon took her to a bookstore and later to a dinner in Beverly Hills, which Mann perceived as a “somewhat professional” meeting due to the involvement of an assistant.
Mann recounted being pressured by Weinstein to engage physically during a hotel visit, attempting to mitigate the situation by offering a back rub. Geragos questioned why Mann did not simply leave the room, to which Mann detailed feeling compelled to stay. She also described an incident where she submitted to unwanted advances after initially resisting.
The Associated Press does not typically identify individuals alleging sexual assault unless they consent to be named, as Mann has done in this case.
“`
