In a significant ruling, the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) upheld a UEFA fine against Real Madrid, following an incident involving homophobic chants directed at Pep Guardiola during a Champions League match against Manchester City. The decision highlights ongoing challenges in addressing discrimination in soccer.
CAS judges deemed the chant as “severe discriminatory nature,” rejecting Madrid’s appeal against the 30,000 euros ($35,000) fine and a two-year probation requiring the closure of a section of their stadium during a future Champions League game. The verdict, dated April 14, emphasized the seriousness of the incident, dismissing the notion that it was merely playful banter.
The contentious chant occurred when Madrid hosted Manchester City in February the previous year, where some fans taunted Guardiola with offensive remarks. A court expert indicated these chants implied the former Barcelona coach was “infected with HIV/AIDS.” Madrid’s legal team argued that such expressions, although potentially offensive, should be viewed in context, particularly when targeting public figures.
Historical Context of Discrimination in Soccer
UEFA’s legal argument underscored the long-standing issue of homophobia in soccer, which they described as casting “a long and deeply troubling shadow” over the sport. They highlighted a culture of “machismo, exclusion, prejudice, and hostility” that has impacted many within the soccer community, sometimes with tragic consequences.
Legal Battles Between Real Madrid and UEFA
The appeal, heard in Lausanne, Switzerland, last September, was part of a broader legal conflict between Madrid and UEFA, including a dispute over the Super League project. UEFA’s legal team argued that Real Madrid should actively oppose such chants instead of challenging the sanctions.
The fine was minimal compared to Madrid’s Champions League earnings, which exceeded 100 million euros ($117 million) that season. The offending chant, captured and shared on social media, was submitted to UEFA by the Fare Network, an organization collaborating with FIFA to identify discrimination in international soccer.
Real Madrid’s Response
Real Madrid’s lawyers criticized the Fare Network’s report, citing “serious formal and substantive defects.” Initially, Madrid contended that the chants could have been from Manchester City fans. Despite the ongoing legal conflicts, Madrid and UEFA have since resolved their Super League dispute.
In anticipation of another match against Manchester City, Madrid officials reportedly engaged with fan groups to prevent further abuse directed at Guardiola.
___
AP soccer: https://apnews.com/hub/soccer
