Unexpected medical bills for preventive health services can be a frustrating experience for patients who expect certain checkups to be free under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). The ACA mandates that many preventive services, such as screenings and vaccinations, should come at no cost to patients when they visit providers within their insurance network. However, billing issues and misunderstandings often lead to unexpected charges.
In a health economics class, a student expressed surprise after receiving a bill of over $500 for an annual checkup, initially believed to be free. This prompted further discussion on why such discrepancies occur, even when patients are under the impression that preventive services are covered. Often, these unexpected expenses stem from coding errors or instances where a visit is billed as a regular office visit rather than preventive care.
For example, a coding error led to a $78 bill for a Pap smear that was expected to be covered under ACA guidelines. After contacting both the insurer and the primary care provider, the mistake was rectified, reducing the bill to zero. Such incidents highlight the importance of scrutinizing bills and understanding insurance coverage.
Understanding Preventive Care Billing
The ACA requires coverage for specific preventive services without cost-sharing, yet not every visit may be covered. If a patient discusses new symptoms or ongoing conditions, additional charges may apply. These charges could be due to services being billed as diagnostic rather than preventive, or because of coding errors.
Patients often struggle to determine which services should be free and why they might be billed unexpectedly. This confusion underscores the need for clearer communication between healthcare providers, insurers, and patients.
Research Insights on Out-of-Pocket Costs
Research conducted by a team including Erin Duffy and Max Crowley revealed that nearly one in four insured respondents in Pennsylvania reported paying out of pocket for their most recent checkup. Based on the 2024 Penn State Lion Poll, 23.5% of respondents had unexpected costs, with an average amount of $68.50.
The study found that individuals unfamiliar with ACA protections were more likely to incur costs for preventive care. Additionally, those who perceived healthcare as unaffordable were also more likely to face charges.
adamkaz/E+ Collection via Getty Images
Addressing Billing Issues
To avoid unexpected charges, patients should verify which preventive services are covered by their insurer before a visit and ensure their provider is in-network. Discussing additional health concerns during a checkup may incur extra charges, so it’s important to clarify any potential costs beforehand.
If a bill arrives, patients should review it alongside their insurer’s explanation of benefits, checking for correct coding and coverage. Errors should be addressed with the provider’s billing office or insurer.
Ultimately, patients should not need to become experts in insurance billing to receive preventive care. Improved transparency in billing and clearer coverage information are crucial for ensuring patients can access necessary care without unexpected financial burdens.
Read more of our stories about Philadelphia and Pennsylvania, or sign up for our Philadelphia newsletter on Substack.
