Glitch at MVD Leads to Noncitizens Voting in Arizona Elections, No Charges Filed
In a recent development concerning Arizona elections, Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell announced that no charges will be pressed against eight noncitizens who voted in past elections. The situation arose due to a glitch at the Motor Vehicle Division (MVD), which inadvertently listed some individuals as citizens.
Until 1996, Arizona did not mandate proof of citizenship for obtaining a driver’s license, leading to some individuals being mistakenly registered as citizens. This oversight was uncovered in 2024, prompting officials to scrutinize voter registrations to confirm citizenship.
Maricopa County Recorder Justin Heap utilized the federal SAVE database to pinpoint 60 potential noncitizens. Of these, eight were confirmed by Mitchell, a Republican, as being noncitizens affected by the MVD error.
Mitchell expressed doubt that a jury would convict these individuals due to the government’s role in the error. “It’s my feeling that a jury would not convict these eight individuals because of the involvement of a government involved glitch if you will,” Mitchell stated during a press briefing on Monday.
No evidence suggests these individuals intentionally registered to vote; rather, they were inadvertently sent ballots. Among them, only one had filled out a voter registration form, clearly indicating their non-citizen status.
Mitchell emphasized her investigation focused on identifying any systemic issues. “I did look at those eight individuals individually. Initially my focus was looking at — was there a systemic problem?” she explained.
Additionally, Mitchell confirmed that her office is not investigating any issues related to the current year’s midterm elections, noting an absence of significant complaints.














