A brewing controversy involving state lawmakers and Tolleson Union High School District Superintendent Jeremy Calles has sparked both a financial audit and a defamation lawsuit. The dispute centers around a land deal and a series of contentious decisions and accusations.
Earlier this year, Calles facilitated a $25 million purchase of buildings from the Isaac Elementary School District, which was in financial receivership. The deal allows Isaac to repay Tolleson over time, including interest. However, the transaction has drawn criticism from Rep. Matt Gress (R-Phoenix), who labeled it as a “predatory loan.” More details can be found here.
Calles has responded to Gress’s allegations by filing a defamation lawsuit, claiming that the statements have harmed his professional reputation. “You should not call somebody a criminal unless they are in fact charged and convicted of a crime, right,” Calles stated.
This legal action occurred as Gress chaired a legislative hearing where a forensic audit of Tolleson’s finances was approved, following concerns about the district’s dealings. Gress has been vocal about perceived “disturbing activity” in Tolleson.
An $80 million domed football stadium
One of the major discussion points is the district’s plan to construct an $80 million domed football stadium. Calles argues the stadium is vital for student safety during extreme heat conditions. “When it’s 115° outside, it’s probably pushing closer to 140°, 150° on that turf,” Calles explained. More on the project can be found here.
Critics, including some lawmakers, have scrutinized the use of voter-approved bonds for the stadium, questioning the clarity of the bond language.
Gun incident
Safety concerns have also been raised following an incident involving a student allegedly bringing a gun to school. The student was initially sent home, but later returned to campus. Calles defended the decision, saying there was no conclusive evidence to justify expulsion. The student was later involved in a separate shooting incident.
Capacity issues
In addition to safety challenges, Tolleson is grappling with uneven student distribution across its six high schools. While some schools are overcrowded, others have space to spare. Calles noted that state open enrollment laws limit the ability to turn away students until schools reach capacity.
Low test scores
The district’s academic performance has also come under scrutiny, with proficiency rates in English and math falling below state averages. Gress argues that these low scores undermine the value of the district’s graduation rates.
